LESSON
Selecting Effective Treatment Methods
bookmark lesson

You must log in before viewing this lesson.

Print Version
LESSON: Selecting Effective Treatment Methods
CONTENT AREA: Personal & Consumer Health
GRADE LEVEL: High School
RATING:

Synopsis

Students identify valid sources of health information. Student groups research about the variety of medical treatments.

About this Lesson

Key Concepts

NHES Grades 9-12 Alignments

National Science Standards - High School Alignments

National Language Arts Standards - High School Alignments

Objectives

Skill Emphasis

Preparation

Time Requirements

Materials & Preparation

Make visual_aids:

Have overhead projector.

Have available in class articles from professional health journals, contemporary magazines read by students and newspapers. Articles should address a particular health topic, if possible (e.g., nutrition, exercise), so students can compare the information presented.

Have available in class some information about alternative, holistic, folk or complementary medicine.

Teacher page:

Teaching Steps

  1. 1. Review valid sources of information.
    Discuss ways to determine the validity of information sources. See Identifying Valid Sources for Information.
  2. 2. Students critique validity of health information.
    Divide class into four groups and give each group at least one article from each of the these health information resources - professional health journals, contemporary magazines read by students and newspapers.

    Ask groups to critique the articles and prepare to report to the full class their assessment of the reliability of the information.

  3. 3. Discuss issues involved in selecting medical treatment.
    Visual Aid: Key Issues in Selecting Medical Treatment

    Review the issues involved in selecting medical treatment.

  4. 4. Students research information about alternative, holistic, folk or complementary medicine.
    Visual Aid: Key Issues in Selecting Medical Treatment

    Assign each of the four student groups (from Step One) one of the following topics:

    • Alternative medicine
    • Holistic medicine
    • Folk medicine
    • Complementary medicine

    Provide access to the Internet or other sources of information for students. Ask students to apply the elements in the visual_aids to the various treatment options, including conventional medical treatments.

  5. 5. Reflect, summarize, and discuss.
    As groups report, develop a consensus list of strengths and weaknesses to be considered when comparing and evaluating treatment options.

    DISCUSSION POINTS

    SKILL DEVELOPMENT

Assessment

Have students select an illness and develop a report that compares a conventional treatment method with an alternative medical practice for that illness. Students should decide which treatment method or which elements of multiple treatment methods they would choose to use and give reasons for their selections. Have students cite references used in their research and assess the validity of the references.

Assessment Criteria

CONCEPTS

ACCESSING INFORMATION

Related Lessons

Related Resources